Yes!  We are happy to recreate your existing plush toys.  We've heard this makes an awesome gift for folks who had a stuffed animal that was near and dear to their hearts but sadly is no longer with them today.  Please note, however, that for safety reasons we do not utilize plastics or metals in our Imaginables stuffed animals.  So for example, if your prior plushie had plastic eyes, we'd do our best to replicate the same look using soft plush materials.